十大最毒化妝品 大廠雅芳、露得清都上榜 - 美妝
By Eden
at 2011-12-07T17:54
at 2011-12-07T17:54
Table of Contents
我不是念化學也不是念化妝品學的,對於許多成分我是不清楚的
但我回這篇文只是想表示
新聞標題殺人以及為何現在的記者素質之差!?
發一篇十大有毒彩妝的聳動新聞
是否應該給予更多的證明?!而不是只是製造恐慌
首先,ettoday這篇報導可能是承襲自香港大紀元或是中國評論的新聞吧
香港大紀元還有原新聞出處,ETTODAY甚麼出處都沒有。
香港大紀元原文:http://hk.epochtimes.com/b5/11/12/7/148302.htm
次之,這篇新聞報導的原文出處是在Bloomberg網站
Slide Show: The Ten Most Toxic Cosmetics
原文:http://ppt.cc/O3U0
該文也很有種的寫出了記者的名字
1.Aveeno Washing Sunscreen 官網找不到此商品
文中指出octinoxate(桂皮酸鈉,台灣許可並且被經常使用的防曬劑之一)
it's also been linked to thyroid and brain signal problems in lab animals.
2.NARS Firming Foundation Liquid 品牌官網無此商品
因為該產品有Oxybenzone(也是防曬劑)可能引發皮膚刺激或過敏,
就被列入十大有毒化妝品之一???
這成份也沒被禁用,何來有毒之說?怎樣有毒?
3.Flesh-Eating Paste
這是甚麼我還真的不知道!看文章說是藝妓之類在使用的特殊化妝顏料
4.Milani Mosaic Powder 品牌官網無此商品
"may be getting a double dose of retinyl palmitate"
retinyl palmitate這成分的用途我不清楚
查了一下是指說,過多的retinyl palmitate可能致癌
但也有《美國皮膚病學會雜誌》其中有收錄的研究指出此成分是安全的。*1
在沒有完全確定這成分是有毒的情況下就說它有毒,就是街談巷議
5.Revlon ColorStay Cheek Color Mineral Blush 露華濃 ColorStay腮紅礦物腮紅
文中指出玫瑰石英 (rose quartz)和二氧化矽(silica)對呼吸系統可能有影響
並已被證明有毒
(石英的組成成分就叫做二氧化矽好嗎)
吸入過多的silica是會對肺部造成影響,但你是在礦場工作的人嗎
你每天會吸入這麼多的silica嗎
如果有文獻證明silica附著在皮膚上會造成病變,那再來說嘴吧
6.Orly Nail Laquer Orly指甲油
標題是寫Safer Formulas
為何經過轉來轉去的新聞後變成十大最毒化妝品之一呢??????????
噢,原來只要新聞轉來轉去,較為安全的產品就變最毒化妝品
7.Almay Line Smoothing Under-eye concealer
該文再度提及retinyl palmitate。請見上面的第4項產品
8.Neutrogena Weightless Volume Wax Free Mascara
hmmmm....這款台灣沒販售且也已經停售了。
把停產的東西拿來出講那還真的講不完啊
9.Tropez Smoky Eyes Eye Liner
文中說octenylsuccinate被認為與神經毒性,發育和生殖的危害有關
不過此成分被FDA(美國食品藥物管理局)批准有限度地作為食品添加劑的使用
然後,有篇文獻指出:
「口腔研究使用 Octenylsuccinate或與其有關的鈉鹽,
無全身不良,生殖或發育的影響。」
該文獻簡而言之,是說高級的(起碼是有品牌的吧)化妝品在此成分的使用上是安全的。*2
10.Avon Beyond Color Radiant Lifting Eyeshadow
停產了。
11.Smashbox Lips Treatment SPF 15 台灣官網無,美國網站有
文中提及的retinyl palmitate請見第4項、oxybenzone請見第2項
然後文內說,
「一些品牌的唇膏含有鉛,可攝入和在體內積累,可能會導致學習和行為障礙。」
沒在這樣產品裡說它含有鉛,卻在文裡說其他未知的產品
這是甚麼樣的論述啊?看起來就會誤導人以為它含有鉛啊
標題還寫Chemical Lipstick。
就算是使用天然成分的產品也幾乎會加防腐劑,不然沒多久就細菌孳生了
最後,根據香港大紀元轉來轉去的報導指出
美國環境保護團體「環境工作小組」(Environmental Working Group)
羅列出十大最毒化妝品
我去Environmental Working Group網站(http://www.ewg.org/)逛了很久
找不到這則新聞耶
是怎樣可以新聞本身亂報
被轉一手還是亂報
再轉一手乾脆省些麻煩直接列出廠牌和名稱的亂報新聞簡單版啊
記者,加油好嗎?
*1
Wang, SQ; Dusza, SW; Lim, HW (2010). "Safety of retinyl palmitate in
sunscreens: a critical analysis.". Journal of the American Academy of
Dermatology 63 (5)
http://www.eblue.org/article/S0190-9622(10)00850-9/fulltext
*2
Nair B, Yamarik TA (2002). "Final report on the safety assessment of
aluminum starch octenylsuccinate." . Cosmetic Ingredient Review Expert panel.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12042058
: ====================================================
: http://www.ettoday.net/news/20111207/11168.htm
: 十大最毒化妝品 大廠雅芳、露得清都上榜
Tags:
美妝
All Comments
By Mia
at 2011-12-11T17:36
at 2011-12-11T17:36
By Liam
at 2011-12-16T09:07
at 2011-12-16T09:07
By Caroline
at 2011-12-18T04:32
at 2011-12-18T04:32
By Isla
at 2011-12-21T04:49
at 2011-12-21T04:49
By Joseph
at 2011-12-24T17:02
at 2011-12-24T17:02
By Mia
at 2011-12-27T04:35
at 2011-12-27T04:35
By Suhail Hany
at 2011-12-29T12:59
at 2011-12-29T12:59
By Gary
at 2012-01-01T23:24
at 2012-01-01T23:24
By Dinah
at 2012-01-04T10:13
at 2012-01-04T10:13
By Elvira
at 2012-01-07T05:13
at 2012-01-07T05:13
By Caroline
at 2012-01-07T11:43
at 2012-01-07T11:43
By Damian
at 2012-01-09T07:59
at 2012-01-09T07:59
By Harry
at 2012-01-12T06:42
at 2012-01-12T06:42
By Andrew
at 2012-01-14T05:08
at 2012-01-14T05:08
By Margaret
at 2012-01-15T04:18
at 2012-01-15T04:18
By Skylar Davis
at 2012-01-17T00:36
at 2012-01-17T00:36
By Una
at 2012-01-19T04:35
at 2012-01-19T04:35
By Kristin
at 2012-01-20T15:18
at 2012-01-20T15:18
By Edwina
at 2012-01-24T15:44
at 2012-01-24T15:44
By Jack
at 2012-01-25T09:44
at 2012-01-25T09:44
By Rachel
at 2012-01-28T12:23
at 2012-01-28T12:23
By Jacky
at 2012-01-29T05:17
at 2012-01-29T05:17
By Zanna
at 2012-02-03T02:00
at 2012-02-03T02:00
By Faithe
at 2012-02-04T08:58
at 2012-02-04T08:58
By Joe
at 2012-02-05T01:00
at 2012-02-05T01:00
By Hedda
at 2012-02-07T04:06
at 2012-02-07T04:06
By James
at 2012-02-10T15:20
at 2012-02-10T15:20
By Zora
at 2012-02-11T14:27
at 2012-02-11T14:27
By Anonymous
at 2012-02-12T17:31
at 2012-02-12T17:31
By John
at 2012-02-16T07:47
at 2012-02-16T07:47
By Necoo
at 2012-02-19T05:08
at 2012-02-19T05:08
By Erin
at 2012-02-21T01:45
at 2012-02-21T01:45
By Dorothy
at 2012-02-24T19:26
at 2012-02-24T19:26
By Jacky
at 2012-02-29T15:14
at 2012-02-29T15:14
By Franklin
at 2012-03-01T14:45
at 2012-03-01T14:45
By Kristin
at 2012-03-04T13:00
at 2012-03-04T13:00
By Blanche
at 2012-03-05T14:57
at 2012-03-05T14:57
By Zanna
at 2012-03-09T13:43
at 2012-03-09T13:43
Related Posts
Solone新10色眼影盤(送)超防水眼線液筆
By Brianna
at 2011-12-07T17:54
at 2011-12-07T17:54
膚蕊無瑕礦物BB霜小瓶裝的有出健康膚色?
By Blanche
at 2011-12-07T16:02
at 2011-12-07T16:02
maybelline baby lips 2條52!!!!
By Christine
at 2011-12-07T15:56
at 2011-12-07T15:56
冏rz。DIOR MASCARA DIORSHOW搶眼睫毛膏
By Oliver
at 2011-12-07T15:44
at 2011-12-07T15:44
DIOR BB霜
By Emma
at 2011-12-07T14:41
at 2011-12-07T14:41